Labour Law Amendments – Pros and Cons


The Prime Minister while interacting with Chief Ministers of various states during the lockdown had discussed about the revamping, restructuring and restarting the commercial and industrial process within the country in the coming days.

Indian labour laws differed from the labour laws of other countries of the world as it had distinction which represents state’s position with respecdt to both capital and labour. These laws held irrelevant to about 90 percent of India’s labour force. Very rarely, do they seem to protect a small section of the great labour force. had the unique distinction of representing the state’s war on both capital and labour. They were irrelevant to 90 per cent of India’s labour force. According to KR Shyam Sundar these laws are “not even a paper tiger”.

The idea that Indian labour’s bargaining power was an obstacle to India’s industrialisation is errant nonsense. While people may think that the labour laws were helping industrialists, in actual sense, nothing was like that.

It was really necessary by the government to look at these laws afresh. It was on this inspirational note of the P.M., the Government of M.P., Gujrat and U.P. had announced to amend their labour laws. Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, and Gujarat state governments have relaxed labour laws in a bid to attract investment and restart economic activity that was paralysed by the nationwide coronavirus-induced lockdown. Punjab, Himachal Pradesh and Gujarat have also amended their Factories Acts and increased the work hours from 8 to 12 hours a day or 72 hours per week.

Following are a few highlights of the aforesaid in the states like U.P. , M.P. and Gujarat:-

  • The U.P. cabinet has brought an ordinance namely ” U.P. Temporary Exemption from certain Labour Laws Ordinance 2020″ that was passed on 7th of may 2020 .Post amendment, the only applicable law would be Building and under construction workers Act,1996.
  • Provisions related to child and female labour has been kept alive.
  • Provisions related to Trade Unions have been repealed.
  • Provisions related to Industrial disputes resolution system, commercial security, health issues have been repealed. 
  • Provisions related to contract and migrants labour have been abolished.
  • M.P. has amended in terms of relaxation in working shifts as per the convenience of the employer.
  • M.P. has further amended labour laws under which factories having less than 50 workers are not under the purview of Labor Law.
  • M.P. has further amended provisions in labour laws by   proposing no interference of labor court and labor department in the matters related to actions against labourers.
  • Gujarat has made License and Registration process of the Institution under labour laws to become easy and time saving.
  • Factories in Gujarat are not supposed to be inspected by labour inspector under the amended labour laws.

Now as far as the outcome of the above-mentioned amended provisions of labour laws are concerned, it could be like the two sides of the coin. – the lockdown has created a huge mess in the service sector due to which has ultimately generated unemployment, lay-offs etc. Such effort by the various state governments could give a ray of hope to the one who is keen to give a kick to any start up venture –

  • If at all the states succeed in alluring the MNC companies from China to their respective states, that would be a drastic boom to their economy and goes without saying to the country’s economy also.
  • Hassle free and time savy registration process will surely attract more capitalist to initiate into some more ventures which Will no doubt generate employment
  • With the starting of industries, the ex-chequer will also enjoy a candy in terms of generation of revenue.

On the other hand, some experts opine that-

  • There could be a possibility of occurrence of exploitation of labour because of repealing provisions like inspection of factories.
  • The process of Non affiliation of Trade Unions may at times shut the genuine approach of the labours
  • The rights guaranteed by Articles 14, 19 and 21 of our Constitution seems to be hardly accessible to the labours under the amended provisions.

Conclusively, the bottom line requirement of  “रोटी, कपड़ा और मकान ” has unfortunately no alternative for the poor, stranded and helpless labours of the country and in a manner beneficial for them also as is always said that something is better than nothing

Disclaimer :- This post is independently published by the author. Infeed neither backs nor assumes liability for the opinions put forth by the author.

Share post:



More like this

Pratapgarhi speaks against the demolition of 700-year-old mosque in Rajya Sabha

Congress leader Imran Pratapgarhi, in a poetic yet eloquent...

The Stealthy Rise of Autocracy: India’s Democratic Crisis Unveiled

Suspending MPs to strengthen Parliament security? Slow and steady...

After Bharat Jodo Yatra, Rahul Gandhi to go on Bharat Nyay Yatra from Jan 14 to March 20

The Congress on December 27 announced that party leader...

Equality’s Architect: Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and the Crafting of India’s Constitution

Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's life is marked by his profound...